Phone numbers and email addresses answer to different federal laws. Here is how to tell which one governs each part of your campaign before you send a single message.

Main points

  • The channel decides the law: messages to phone numbers fall under the TCPA, while commercial email falls under CAN-SPAM, even if no one opted in.
  • Marketing texts need prior express written consent before the first message, with disclosures about the program, frequency and possible data rates at the point of opt-in.
  • CAN-SPAM works on an opt-out model, so unsolicited commercial email is allowed if headers, subject lines, ad labeling, a postal address and a working opt-out are in place.
  • TCPA penalties run $500 per violating text, up to $1,500 if willful, and each message can count as a separate violation that recipients can stack.
  • CAN-SPAM penalties reach $53,088 per violating email, and both the promoted company and the vendor that sends the message can be held liable.

One lead generation funnel often produces two kinds of traffic: email sends to people who filled out a form, and text or call follow ups to the phone numbers from the same form. Those channels answer to different federal laws, and the law that applies is decided by where the message lands, not by what you are selling. Getting that assignment wrong is one of the fastest ways to turn a profitable campaign into a legal problem.

One Campaign, Two Laws: Why the Channel Determines the Rules

What determines which law applies is the destination of the message. Call or text a phone number, and the TCPA governs, with enforcement from the FCC, state attorneys general, and private plaintiffs who can sue directly. Land the message in an email inbox, and CAN-SPAM takes over, enforced by the FTC, and it applies to all commercial messages, not just bulk blasts. The law defines commercial messages as email whose primary purpose is advertising or promoting a product or service, and it makes no exception for business-to-business email.

That channel-based split surprises affiliates who assume one compliance setup covers the whole funnel. It does not. An email program that is fully compliant can sit next to a text program that violates the TCPA on its first message, because the two statutes start from opposite assumptions about consent.

Calls add a third layer. The FTC’s Telemarketing Sales Rule, amended several times since the original rule issued in 1995, layers Do Not Call requirements on top of the TCPA for outbound sales calls. Many states have their own telemarketing laws, some with private rights of action. For the phone side of a campaign, assume the strictest applicable rule governs.

Before the first promotional text goes out, the TCPA demands written consent that is prior and express. The agreement has to be clear and cannot be a condition of making a purchase, so a clause tucked into a checkout flow carries no weight. Non-promotional messages such as shipping alerts sit under a lower bar: prior express consent, which a customer gives by supplying their number for transactional updates.

Consent is not valid unless the disclosures are in place. At the point of opt-in, you must disclose the program’s name, how often messages will arrive, and a notice that message and data rates may apply, along with direct links to the sender’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Consent fails entirely if you never spell out what the person is agreeing to.

The penalty structure is what makes the TCPA the scarier of the two statutes for most affiliates:

  • $500 per individual text sent in violation, rising to $1,500 per text for willful violations.
  • Each noncompliant element of a message can count as a separate violation, and a consumer can stack the penalties.
  • A recipient does not need to prove actual damages. Receiving a noncompliant text is enough to establish standing.
  • Because a campaign can reach thousands of numbers, text cases are well suited to class action certification, and state mini-TCPA laws add parallel exposure.

The math scales fast. Text 5,000 people once without valid consent, and the statutory damages total $2.5 million at the base rate. If a court finds the violations willful, that figure triples to $7.5 million.

Timing rules apply too. Marketing texts may only be sent between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 p.m. local time, where local means the recipient’s physical location at the moment the text arrives, not their area code. Consumers must also have an easy way out, which means honoring opt-out keywords promptly.

Calls carry their own rules. A prerecorded robocall selling something is illegal unless the company has written permission, and live sales calls generally require either a recent business relationship or written permission from the consumer, with the National Do Not Call Registry setting the baseline for numbers you cannot dial. Our article on the Do Not Call Registry for lead generation covers that list in detail.

CAN-SPAM at a Glance: Commercial Email Requirements

CAN-SPAM, passed in 2003, takes the opposite approach to consent. There is no opt-in requirement. You can generally send commercial email to a purchased or scraped list as long as you follow the initiator requirements, and you can keep sending until the recipient asks you to stop. That makes email far easier to start than SMS, and it is a major reason email remains the default first channel for testing offers.

The tradeoff is a checklist that applies to every single message:

  • Accurate header information, including From, Reply-To and originating domain, that identifies who initiated the message.
  • Subject lines that accurately reflect the message content.
  • A clear and conspicuous disclosure that the message is an advertisement.
  • A valid physical postal address, which can be a street address, a USPS-registered post office box, or a registered private mailbox at a commercial mail receiving agency.
  • A clear opt-out mechanism, honored within ten business days.

Two details catch affiliates off guard. First, consent buys you almost nothing under CAN-SPAM: if recipients gave prior affirmative consent, you are exempt only from identifying the message as an ad. Accurate headers, a valid postal address and a working opt-out still apply to your opted-in list.

Penalties reach $53,088 per violating email, and each separate email counts. In August 2024, the FTC imposed a $2.95 million penalty on the security camera company Verkada, the largest fine the agency has issued under the Act. Liability also reaches the advertiser whose product is promoted as well as the vendor doing the sending, so running email for an advertiser does not shift the compliance risk off your books.

The table below puts the two statutes next to each other on the questions that come up most often. The TCPA column applies when your traffic reaches phone numbers. The CAN-SPAM column applies to commercial email, including email sent on behalf of an advertiser. If you run both, you need to satisfy both columns for the respective channels; neither substitutes for the other. Email suits teams testing offers quickly and working from bought or scraped lists; SMS suits teams with a warm, opted-in phone list and the patience to build a proper consent flow.

Question TCPA (calls and texts to phone numbers) CAN-SPAM (commercial email)
Do you need consent first? Yes, prior express written consent for promotional texts, and it cannot be a condition of purchase No opt-in required; send until the recipient opts out
Must you identify the message? Opt-in disclosures must state the program name, frequency, possible data rates, and link to Terms and Privacy Policy Every message must clearly identify itself as an ad, unless recipients gave prior affirmative consent
How do recipients stop messages? Opt-out keywords must be honored promptly A clear opt-out notice in every email, honored within ten business days
Timing restrictions Marketing texts only between 8

a.m. and 9

p.m. in the recipient’s local time

No federal time-of-day restriction
Penalty exposure $500 per violating text, up to $1,500 if willful, with stacking and private lawsuits Up to $53,088 per violating email, enforced by the FTC
Who enforces Private plaintiffs, the FCC and state enforcers The FTC, the FCC, state enforcers and internet service providers

Pro tip

Before a launch, write down the destination of every message in the funnel: email address or phone number. That single line tells you which statute’s consent, labeling and opt-out rules you are working under.

Where the Lines Blur

The channel rule is simple until it is not. The main exception is email sent to addresses hosted by wireless carriers, sometimes called mobile service commercial messages. These are still email, so CAN-SPAM governs, but the FCC has its own rule for them, and messages to wireless email domains require express prior authorization rather than the usual opt-out model. This corner of the market is rare, and for most SMS programs the real financial risk sits with the TCPA and state telemarketing laws.

Auto-dialers blur things in the other direction. Equipment does not change the law; the phone number does. A robocall or an autodialed text to a phone number is a TCPA question regardless of how the message is produced.

Blurring also happens inside a funnel. A lead who opts into email has consented to email, nothing more. If the same lead then gets texts, the text program needs its own consent that meets the TCPA’s written standard with full disclosures. International traffic adds another layer: CAN-SPAM’s opt-out model is US-specific, and rules like Europe’s GDPR require explicit opt-in consent before marketing email, so a list with overseas recipients has to meet the stricter standard.

A Quick Decision List for Your Next Campaign

  • Sending to an email address? CAN-SPAM applies, and the full checklist does too, even for a consented list.
  • Sending to a phone number by text? TCPA applies, and you need prior express written consent with complete opt-in disclosures before the first promotional message.
  • Placing outbound sales calls? Check the Do Not Call Registry, rely only on an existing business relationship or written permission as your exemption, and remember robocalls selling anything require written permission.
  • Sending email to carrier-hosted addresses? That is still CAN-SPAM, but with the FCC’s stricter authorization rule for wireless email domains.
  • Running both email and SMS from one lead flow? Track consent separately for each channel and never assume one covers the other.
  • Mailing anyone outside the US? Expect opt-in rules like GDPR to apply alongside CAN-SPAM.

What to Change When a Campaign Moves From Email to SMS

Affiliates who migrate a working email campaign to SMS tend to carry over assumptions that do not survive the switch. The opt-out-only model is the biggest one. Email lets you send first and honor opt-outs later; a text program needs opt-in consent before the first marketing message, so your email suppress list and your SMS consent list are different files with different legal meaning.

Practically, the migration means building a new opt-in flow with the required disclosures, including the program name, message frequency and the message and data rates warning, plus links to your Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. It also means new send-time logic that respects the 8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. window in each recipient’s local time, and a suppression process that acts on opt-out keywords immediately. Before you spend against the new channel, test the consent flow and the tracking end to end on a small batch; our guide to testing email traffic on a CPA offer before you scale covers the same discipline.

For a closer look at how consent, opt-outs and disclosure rules interact across a lead funnel, read Consent and Compliance in Lead Generation, and see the real cost of a TCPA violation for lead generators for what a single misstep on the phone side can cost. The destination of each message decides the law, so build the consent trail for each channel separately.

Frequently asked

Does CAN-SPAM require consent before I send commercial email?
No. CAN-SPAM has no opt-in requirement, so you can generally send until the recipient opts out, as long as you meet the initiator requirements. If recipients gave prior affirmative consent, that exempts you only from labeling the message as an ad, not from any other rule.

Do I need written consent to send marketing texts?
Yes. The TCPA requires prior express written consent for promotional texts to phone numbers, and that agreement cannot be a condition of making a purchase. Non-promotional messages such as shipping alerts need a lower level of consent.

If someone opts out of my emails, can I still text them?
An email opt-out does not give you permission to text. Phone numbers need their own consent under the TCPA before the first marketing message, so a move from email to SMS means building a new consent flow.

Are there time limits on when I can send marketing texts?
Yes. Under the TCPA and FCC rules, marketing texts may only be sent between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 p.m. in the recipient’s local time, based on where they physically are when the text arrives, not their area code.

This article is general information for marketers, not legal advice. Advertising, privacy and consumer protection rules vary by country and change over time, so check the current rules and your network’s terms, and get legal advice where needed before running campaigns.